4 Frequently Asked Questions About Singapore’s Self-Help Group Contributions
Key Takeaways
- SHG deductions add small amounts but meaningful payroll compliance complexity.
- Accurate NRIC and religion data is essential for correct fund allocation.
- Opt-out rules make clear employee communication critical.
- Mixed-race and dual-fund cases require consistent HR handling.
- Job changes reset opt-out status, creating repeat admin work.
Details create the big picture.
In Singapore, statutory deductions of salary cover fairly straightforward items like CPF. However, employees are also expected to contribute to self-help groups (SHG) via salary deductions.
At first glance, the ethnically-based SHGs may seem like relics of communalist Singapore, amidst a modern landscape of diversity and looking past the racial divide. However, they continue to play a role in raising socioeconomic levels and providing opportunities to the underprivileged. Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong even hailed the SHGs as organizations that can “better understand the unique characteristics and needs of their different communities” and can also address issues “forthrightly, without raising racial or religious sensitivities.”
What Are the Self-Help Groups?
There are four SHGs in Singapore, representing the Chinese, Muslim, Indian, and Eurasian communities.
Chinese Development Assistance Council (CDAC)
The CDAC, as its name implies, is the SHG that provides for the Chinese community. Contributions to the CDAC Fund are used to finance CDAC's activities and support initiatives aimed at assisting those from lower income groups in overcoming their obstacles and achieving social mobility.
In 2021, the CDAC benefitted 17,700 households. This was mostly done by providing underprivileged students access to education through the Internet, as well as encouraging low-income households to develop healthier eating habits via food vouchers.
Mosque Building and Mendaki Fund (MBMF)
The MBMF was originally conceived as a fund to build mosques at the then-newly developed Housing and Development Board estates in the 1970s. Later on, its remit expanded into funding educational and social programmes for the community through the MENDAKI foundation.
Currently, the MBMF is administered by the Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura (MUIS). Muslim contributors should note that MBMF is not equivalent to zakat, because the aim of zakat as a religious obligation is different to that of the MBMF.
Singapore Indian Development Association (SINDA)
SINDA was established as the SHG to uplift the socio-economic status of the Indian community in Singapore. Each year, SINDA’s help includes maximizing education opportunities, community growth, and honing leadership skills.
Contribution to SINDA is expected from Singaporeans of Indian descent, including Bangladeshis, Bengalis, Parsees, Sikhs, Sinhalese, Telugus, Pakistanis, Sri Lankans, Goanese, Malayalees, Punjabis, Tamils and all people originating from the Indian subcontinent.
Eurasian Community Fund (ECF)
Located at a strategic crossroads, Singapore has had a long history of colonization by the Portuguese, Dutch and the British. As descendants of the Europeans who intermarried with the local population, the Eurasians continue to uphold their unique heritage through the ECF.
As the smallest community among the four ethnic groups, the ECF has higher contribution rates than the other three SHGs.
Who Should Contribute to Which Self-Help Group?
Generally, Singapore citizens and Singapore permanent residents are expected to contribute to SHGs. Employers will deduct these contributions from their salary and pay it to the CPF Board, which is the collecting agent for the SHG funds.
As to which SHG fund they should contribute to, this will follow their race as indicated on their NRIC. For example:
- Siew Meng’s race on his NRIC is indicated as Chinese, and as such he will contribute to the CDAC fund.
- Norainni’s race on her NRIC is indicated as Malay, and as such she will contribute to the MBMF.
- Ravi’s race on his NRIC is indicated as Indian, and as such he will contribute to the SINDA fund.
- Kelvin’s race on his NRIC is indicated as Eurasian, and as such he will contribute to the ECF.
In the case of mixed-race employees, e.g. Chinese-Indian, employers can refer to the first component of the double-barrelled race on the employee’s NRIC to determine which SHGs the employee should contribute to. For example:
- Leena’s race on her NRIC is indicated as Chinese-Indian, and as such she will contribute to the CDAC fund.
All working Muslims in Singapore, regardless of residency (including foreign workers) are also expected to contribute to the MBMF. For example:
- Danial’s race on his NRIC is indicated as Chinese. But if he is a Muslim, he is expected to contribute to both CDAC and MBMF.
Experience how simple payroll can be
Reduce processing time and compliance risks with brioHR’s intuitive payroll system.
Are Self-Help Group Contributions Compulsory?
SHG contributions are not compulsory, but employees need to opt-out of them.
By default, statutory contributions to SHGs will be deducted from employees’ salaries like CPF. However, employees can opt out of these contributions by notifying their corresponding SHG. For example, if a Chinese employee wishes to stop SHG contributions, they will need to contact the CDAC and fill in an opt-out form. This form must be endorsed and a copy filed by the employer.
For employees that are expected to contribute to two funds, e.g. a Chinese-Muslim employee contributing to both CDAC and MBMF, they can opt out of contributing to just one fund. For example, Danial, a Chinese-Muslim employee, can opt to only contribute to CDAC instead of MBMF by contacting MBMF and following their opt-out procedure.
On the other hand, mixed-race employees can contribute to two funds by informing their employer. For example, Chinese-Indian employee Leena can contribute to both the CDAC and SINDA funds if she wants to.
In addition, if the employee changes jobs, they will need to go through the opt-out procedure again for their respective SHGs.
What Are the Self-Help Group Fund Contribution Rates?
Each SHG fund has different contribution rates (click on each image to view full size).
-
- Source: CDAC
-
- Source: MBMF (showing old 2016 rates)
-
- Source: ECF
-
- Source: SINDA
Everything HR.
One login
From payroll to onboarding, brioHR gives you everything you need in one place. Built for busy teams. Backed by people who care.
Conclusion
- Self-Help Group deductions may seem minor, but they represent a recurring compliance detail HR teams can’t afford to overlook.
- Clear employee data and onboarding workflows are the foundation of accurate SHG payroll handling.
- Proactive communication around opt-out rules reduces confusion, disputes, and manual follow-ups.
- Standardizing edge-case handling helps HR scale compliance without increasing admin burden.
To learn more about how brioHR can transform your HR processes, check out BrioHR’s website or request a demo.
